I state that it is a good bag, but i don't give 5 stars because it's not perfect. The leather is of good quality, but if you want to be precise it has some small imperfections due to the craftmentship (little glue spots). In mine there is also a tiny superficial cut, but they are all things that in a leather bag will happen sooner or later, so I don't give much weight. The bag is also quite soft, so it retains its shape only when well filled. All in all I like the product, and considering the price I would say that it's ok. I believe that with the passing of the years it will become more and more beautiful.